Cumbernauld design

Cumbernauld

Winner of the Carbuncle aware – most unloved town, as voted for by its own residents…

Cumbernauld design
Original Cumbernauld design

One of the last new towns in the UK. 10 years after Harlow, with the building of the Gorbals in Glasgow progressing too slowly, a further new town outside of Glasgow was designated. This was a different kind of new town, with a move towards greater compactness – the site was the smallest of any new town, but it was designed to have 3 times the population density of East Kilbride. 

“Concentrating all town centre activities into one central megastructure was a response to previous criticism of new towns (1953 Architectural Review called them “terrifying eternity of wilderness, punctuated by seas of concrete”), and a chance to implement daring new concepts. Geoffrey Copcutt was main architect for this. Architectural Design 1963 had feature on it. 

Whole plan was for a dramatic single building on crest of hill. Crazy in retrospect, multi-storey but open to elements, so like a wind tunnel. But massive amount of under building required, phase 1 ran behind schedule and over budget. Again, businesses reluctant to take on cost and risk, esp on upper levels. So instead of sticking with plan of car park below, shops above, development continued on ground level.

Little of Copcutt’s plan built as intended, many features left out, and much now demolished. Odd glimpses remain – ramps, bridges, stained glass. Were to be penthouses on top! Now mostly privately owned, so not much planners can do. 

In 1967 won international award for community architecture, beating Stockholm and Tapiola, biggest award of any of the new towns. 

Lots of people who worked on town continued to live there. 

In 1967 road traffic accidents were 22% of national average, due to separation of cars and people. But underpasses became unpopular so later development preferred roundabouts. 

Some housing poor quality, but Seafar won awards.

Concretopia – the spirit of the New Towns

“Despite evidence that these early new towns had pleasanter surroundings, better living conditions, social services and recreational facilities than in comparable towns or inner city, there appears to be little love for them beyond their own boundaries. 

“New architects and planners can be contemptuous, critical of the new towns.

“Early new towns were radical, incredible feat of organisation, planning, sheer bloody mindedness. To this day, in an era of faux austerity where political will is such that widening inequality is seen as inevitable, and grand schemes unimaginable, the spirit of these pioneering souls and their projects should still strike even the most curmudgeonly of us as visionary and inspirational.”

[John Grindrod] 

Concretopia

“There is an accepted narrative to the way we think about our postwar architectural legacy.  That narrative is somewhat akin to the plot of a superhero blockbuster: a team of supervillains – planners, architects, academics – have had their corrupt, megalomaniac way with the country for 30 years.  Then, at long last, a band of unlikely heroes – a ragbag of poets, environmentalists and good, honest citizens – rose up against this architectural Goliath and toppled it in the name of Prince Charles.  In this story, prewar modernism equals good, postwar modernism equals bad.

“Hence while early modernism is still much imitated [Channel 4’s Grand Designs with its glass-fronted white boxes], the default word for what we ended up with after the Second World War is “concrete monstrosities”.

“And yet, was that what actually happened?  Were these architects and planners the philistine barbarians of popular myth?  Are the places they planned and built as awful as some might make us believe? And is their legacy one of catastrophic failure?

“After all, they inherited a nation where millions lived in overcrowded conditions in cities, where factories belched toxic fumes onto the slums next door and the most basic sanitation was a dream for millions. It isn’t all that hard to understand the demand for change and the excitement of new ideas.  A mere half century had brought the motorcar and aeroplanes, antibiotics and nuclear physics.  The possibilities for human progress seemed endless, and after the catastrophic upheaval of two wards, people around the world were open to new ways of living.”

[Concretopia, by John Grindrod]  

St Bride's refurbishment 2016

£2 million refurbishment was completed in 2016, mainly to deal with problems of windows, external brickwork and water ingress.

St Bride’s is one of only 42 post-war buildings in Scotland to be listed at Category A.

[Daily Record]

“Ultimately it is hoped to restore the original composition of the structure by rebuilding a feature bell tower which was sadly demolished in 1983. Fundraising to that end is still ongoing following the sad passing of its chief architect, Professor Andy McMillan, with well-wishers being urged to donate to the fund.” [Urban Realm]

Holden House

Steedman's Holden House

Grade B listed, by Morris Steedman, now called Calderstone House.
Quirky shape.  Lots of wood inside.

Holden House
The accommodation is spread over two floors with the living accommodation on the ground floor and a studio on the first floor. The central reception hall gives access to all the rooms with the ‘public’ accommodation consisting of a sitting room, a dining kitchen and a sun room while the sleeping area is made up of four bedrooms. An external staircase leads to a ‘substantial’ studio with two elevated gallery levels and an external balcony with views of the countryside around. There is also a large loft area above the bedrooms.

Not far from Crutherland hotel, secluded spot in woodland.

Murray One to get mix of exterior finishes?

Due refurbishment.  As each separate close gets its own vote there are fears the building will have three different finishes on the outside.
Both blocks of flats are part of the Murray One development, which originally had a white-painted finish on the outside.
They were awarded the prestigious Saltire award for design and were celebrated as an example of excellence in public housing development.
[Daily Record]

Murray One flats